Donovan Catholic Falls to Paramus Catholic, Ending Record-Setting Season

PARAMUS — The way it ended didn’t change fourth-seeded Donovan Catholic’s historic season, the process it took to get here, or the way it’ll be remembered.

Even in a 43-7 road loss to top-seeded Paramus Catholic in the Non-Public B semifinals, the Griffins (10-2) capped off a remarkable season that saw them near the precipice of history.

But the Paladins (7-5) were simply the better team on Friday night.

“They outplayed us, outcoached us, they did everything they had to do to win the game convincingly,” said Donovan Catholic head coach Dan Curcione after the game. “They got a hell of a team, and I wouldn’t be surprised if they raised a trophy.”

Led by a stout defensive effort, Paramus Catholic controlled the game for much of the 48 minutes, and even when it committed its own share of errors, the Paladins worked a big play to take the momentum back.

Senior running back Alex Staten finished his season with 32 yards on 14 carries, often seeing a Paramus Catholic defender before even crossing the line of scrimmage, while senior quarterback Kahden Davis threw for 106 yards and two interceptions, the second on a long deep ball late in the fourth quarter in a running clock, making his return after a three-game absence due to injury.

Donovan Catholic quarterback Kahden Davis returned from injury in Donovan Catholic's season-ending loss to Paramus Catholic (Photo by SidelineSamsShots) - Donovan Catholic Kahden Davis

Donovan Catholic quarterback Kahden Davis returned from injury in Donovan Catholic’s season-ending loss to Paramus Catholic (Photo by SidelineSamsShots)

For the Paladins, it started with junior quarterback Rowan Martin – in place of injured sophomore Walker Snee – and senior running back and Penn State commit Chukwuma Odoh on the offensive end, and an 11-man attack on the other end to contain an efficient Griffins offense.

Martin finished completing six of his nine pass attempts for 159 yards with two touchdowns and an interception, while Odoh racked up 109 yards from scrimmage and three touchdowns, with 56 yards rushing with two scores on 11 carries, and 53 yards receiving on two catches and another touchdown.

Through the opening stretch of the first quarter, it looked like the two teams were headed for a low-scoring slugfest, as the first three drives of the game ended in three-and-outs.

Both teams had their chances, but the opposing defensive lines created problems in the run and pass game. On the second drive, Staten stood in the Wildcat on third-and-one after runs of four and five yards, but the snap went high and through his hands for a 15-yard loss to end what was shaping up to be a promising drive.

“I just felt like it wasn’t the team that played all year,” added Curcione. “We just didn’t play very well, and we didn’t execute. So, it’s a shame to come out and do that in a big game like this, and against a really super talented team. They were a big part of it as well, why that was happening.”

Paramus Catholic quickly took advantage.

Martin ran for 19 yards to work further into Donovan Catholic territory, and on the very next play, Odoh sprinted up the middle for a 27-yard touchdown to open the scoring. Those two quick strikes signified the Paladins had found their stride on offense, and the Griffins would need to keep up in order to stay in the game.

On the ensuing drive, Davis and sophomore quarterback Chris McClaren shared snaps, but the Paramus Catholic defense stopped both, forcing another three-and-out.

Donovan Catholic quarterback Chris McClaren (Photo by SidelineSamsShots) - Donovan Catholic Chris McClaren

Donovan Catholic quarterback Chris McClaren (Photo by SidelineSamsShots)

The Paladins then worked their first methodical drive of the evening, marching down the field in another five plays, including a 36-yard gain on a screen pass from Martin to Odoh. Two plays later, Martin connected with junior wideout AJ Lopez to open up a two-score lead on the first play of the second quarter.

Paramus Catholic’s defense continued to step up, forcing another three-and-out for the fourth consecutive drive, and gave the ball back to a humming Paladins offense.

Martin once again led his unit down the field in an efficient manner, while also working the big plays, including a 44-yard strike to junior wideout Feury Diaz-Rinaldi. Then, facing a third-and-long, the junior signal-caller lofted a 17-yard score to Odoh on a wheel route to take a commanding three-score lead after just 16 minutes of game action.

Donovan Catholic finally worked some offensive momentum on the ensuing drive, as Davis evaded numerous rushers on third down and fired a 30-yard dart along the sideline to senior receiver Nyron Snerling to work into opposing territory, the Griffins’ first first down of the night.

The Paladins stole the momentum back three plays later, though, stripping the ball away from Staten on a third-down carry.

Once again, Paramus Catholic quickly responded with a six-play, 78-yard drive, capped off by a seven-yard score from Odoh on his 11th and final carry.

On the ensuing drive, Curcione opted to go for it on fourth-and-one at the Griffins’ 45-yard line – an easy decision given the four-score margin – but Staten was stuffed at the line of scrimmage for a turnover. But senior defensive back Ja’el Hester gave Donovan Catholic a spark, intercepting a pass from Martin on the very next play as he attempted to roll out and throw the ball away.

But the momentum would be short-lived.

Facing another third-and-long, Davis rolled outside of the pocket and launched a deep ball that fell short of his intended target, and right into the arms of sophomore defensive back James Brown. With plenty of space and a convoy of blockers, Brown sprinted the other way into the end zone for another score in the final minute of the first half.

Both teams managed a touchdown in the second half, with Paramus Catholic turning to its second team the rest of the way on a running clock.

Donovan Catholic punter Sal Reynoso (Photo by SidelineSamsShots) - Donovan Catholic Sal Reynoso

Donovan Catholic punter Sal Reynoso (Photo by SidelineSamsShots)

Davis helped lead the Griffins’ lone scoring drive late in the third quarter, completing another pass along the sideline to sophomore receiver Torrence Turner, before connecting with senior wideout Aidan Kelly on a third-down pop pass. Kelly turned upfield and outran the secondary for a 66-yard touchdown.

On the ensuing drive, the Paladins worked a big play on a pop pass as well, with sophomores Jimmy Derwin and Camerson Thomas connecting for a 64-yard gain. Junior running back Chris Aldana finished off the final score with a six-yard score on the next play.

As the final whistle blew, and the teams huddled up at their respective sides, between the tears and disappointment of Donovan Catholic’s season coming to a close, was a coach proud of a wildly productive unit.

“We got beat by a better team tonight,” said Curcione. “That’s that, but that doesn’t take away what this group did. This group set a record for wins in a season for us, and they’re a tremendous group to coach, and I’m proud of the season that they had, minus tonight, obviously, but I’m proud of them, and I love coaching them.”

The culmination of a standout season came from the Griffins’ core, which battled through tough times but stuck together and reached new heights.

“Two years ago we were 2-7,” Curcione added. “We weren’t a very good ball club, and we didn’t have a lot of players in the program, and a lot of these guys came and played for us anyway. And I think back on, you know, on the Alex Statens, the Jael Hesters, and Kahden Davis’s, you know, the Sean Byrnes, the Henry Byrnes, and Diondre Foendoes, guys that stuck it out and got us back to this point. We’ve been at this point before and we plan on coming back again.”

Even after coming up short of its first state title berth in 50 years, with a large and productive senior class, Donovan Catholic will move onward to build on the successes of the 2026 unit.

“We’re gonna do what we always do. We’re gonna go back to work with the next group and prepare them as best we can, you know, we’ll continue relatively soon. We’re gonna get right back in the weight room and do it again.”