One Goal Short of Glory: St. John Vianney Falls in Overtime in Non-Public A Final

FRANKLIN TOWNSHIP — St. John Vianney spent much of Saturday’s Non-Public A state championship knocking on the door, creating scoring opportunities, and putting relentless pressure on Immaculate Heart Academy. Even after falling behind in the first half, the Lancers refused to let their championship hopes slip away without a fight.

For nearly 80 minutes, St. John Vianney did everything it could to extend its historic season. Senior Gabby Parker delivered a dramatic equalizer with just over seven minutes remaining in regulation, giving the Lancers new life and putting them within one goal of capturing a state championship.

But after battling back and threatening to complete the comeback, St. John Vianney saw its season end in heartbreaking fashion.

Riley Marino scored with 1:59 remaining in the first overtime to lift Immaculate Heart Academy to a 2-1 victory, denying the Lancers their first Non-Public A state championship and bringing an emotional end to one of the most successful seasons in program history.

“We spoke at halftime about the mental toughness,” SJV head coach Heather Bailey said. “We have been in these situations before in games throughout the year. I am so proud of this group. We played with so much heart and we played tough.”

The Lancers had their opportunities to take control long before the decisive overtime goal. Parker, an Iona commit, was a constant threat to the Blue Eagles’ defense, creating scoring chances from distance and forcing IHA to devote additional attention to slowing her down.

One of Parker’s best opportunities came midway through the first half when she unleashed a shot from approximately 30 yards that struck the crossbar. It was an early indication of the problems she would create for Immaculate Heart throughout the afternoon.

St. John Vianney nearly broke through again with just under six minutes remaining before halftime, but another promising scoring opportunity went unfinished. The missed chance proved costly when IHA quickly counterattacked, and Meryl Lawson found the back of the net with 5:35 remaining in the half to give the Blue Eagles a 1-0 advantage.

Gabby Parker (10) tied the game with 7:12 left for SJV in the Non-Public A Final at Franklin HS. 11/15/26 (Photo by Samantha Mayer) - SJVparker1

Gabby Parker (10) tied the game with 7:12 left for SJV in the Non-Public A Final at Franklin HS. 11/15/26 (Photo by Samantha Mayer)

Despite the setback, the Lancers continued to attack, carrying their offensive pressure into the second half.

Parker frequently drew double teams as IHA attempted to contain her, but St. John Vianney continued to generate scoring opportunities, particularly on corner kicks. Junior Kennedy Wallace repeatedly delivered dangerous balls into the penalty area, putting the Blue Eagles’ defense under pressure.

In the 51st minute, Parker nearly pulled the Lancers even when she worked her way past a defender and created an opportunity in front of the goal, only to send her attempt approximately a foot wide.

As the minutes continued to disappear, St. John Vianney’s chances of extending its season appeared to be fading. But with 7:12 remaining in regulation, the Lancers finally broke through on the type of opportunity they had been creating throughout the game.

Wallace sent another dangerous corner kick into the middle of the box, where Parker connected to score the equalizer and bring St. John Vianney level at 1-1.

For Parker, the goal represented another defining moment in a senior season that nearly never materialized after injuries disrupted the first half of her high school career.

“That is Gabby Parker, she cares so much,” Bailey said. “We were robbed of some of her high school career because she got hurt her freshman year in her first game. She did not play again really until her junior year. For her to have this state run is awesome. She is a great kid that works so hard and cares about everyone.”

Kennedy Wallace assisted the equalizer for SJV in the Non-Public A Final against IHA. 11/15/26 (Photo by Samantha Mayer) - DU9A8960

Kennedy Wallace assisted the equalizer for SJV in the Non-Public A Final against IHA. 11/15/26 (Photo by Samantha Mayer)

Parker finished her senior season with 17 goals and totaled 28 over her final two years after injuries limited her opportunities during her freshman and sophomore seasons.

“Her (Parker) talent speaks for herself,” Bailey said. “She is going to do great things at Iona. I am just so honored that I got a chance to be her coach for her four years here.”

The Lancers nearly completed the comeback before overtime, earning another corner kick in the final minute of regulation. Wallace once again delivered the ball into a dangerous area, but St. John Vianney was unable to get a clean shot away near the back of the box.

Despite coming up short, Parker said there was never any doubt about the team’s determination to fight its way back into the game.

“She (Coach Bailey) didn’t have to say anything,” Parker said. “We knew we wanted it. We always wanted it. As a team we all have the same goal. She fired us a bit more. We knew what we had to do when we came back out in the second-half. Unfortunately, it did not go our way, but I am so proud of us.”

Maya Pflug (right) and Gabby Parker (left) celebrating the game tying goal against IHA. 11/15/26 (Photo by Samantha Mayer) - DU9A8433

Maya Pflug (right) and Gabby Parker (left) celebrating the game tying goal against IHA. 11/15/26 (Photo by Samantha Mayer)

Senior Maya Pflug anchored a back line that limited Immaculate Heart’s opportunities throughout regulation. In the 16th minute, Pflug demonstrated her defensive ability by chasing down an IHA forward and preventing a clean shot on goal.

Her performance was particularly impressive considering she had spent much of her high school career playing outside back before transitioning to center back this season.

“Maya Pflug is not even a natural center back,” Bailey said. “She was turned into a center back this year. She has been playing outside back for us. I am biased, but I think she is one of the best center backs in the state, not just the Shore Conference. She is a smart player that makes you work hard and always makes the right decision.”

Pflug was part of a veteran defensive unit that helped carry the Lancers through their historic postseason run. Alongside seniors Gianna Cerniglia and Hannah Martiak, she helped form a back line that proved especially important in St. John Vianney’s 2-1 victory over Paul VI in the South Jersey Non-Public A championship.

Paul VI entered that sectional final having scored 88 goals, averaging nearly four per game, but the Lancers held the Eagles to just one.

“The defensive people do not get the glory,” Bailey said. “She (Pflug) was huge for us in the win against Paul VI anchoring the back line. I have three seniors back there. Gianna Cerniglia and Hannah Martiak, who stepped into the other center back role. Those three really took the challenge in leading our line. It was a great group effort throughout the state run.”

That same defensive determination helped keep St. John Vianney within striking distance against Immaculate Heart, until Marino’s overtime winner ultimately ended the Lancers’ hopes of bringing home a state championship.

“I thought we were knocking throughout the game,” Bailey said. “Full credit to IHA. That girl made a great shot to end it. It was just a great battle between two really great teams. We battled back and Gabby Parker got that corner to tie it. I told the girls I cannot be upset with our effort and with how we played. We represented St. John Vianney as best we could.”

Although the Lancers fell one victory short of the ultimate prize, their postseason run represented a significant milestone for a program that had waited more than two decades to return to the sectional championship stage.

St. John Vianney captured its first sectional title since 2004 and became the first Shore Conference non-public girls soccer team to reach a state group championship game since St. Rose accomplished the feat in 2018.

For Bailey, those accomplishments were about more than the championships and victories. They reflected the commitment of a senior class that helped elevate the program and establish a standard for the teams that will follow.

“These girls are the program,” Bailey said. “It shows the amount of hard work they are willing to put in. This is a big step for the program to say that we are a program that will compete hard, win big games and have the ability to do special things.”

The Lancers may have left Franklin Township without the championship trophy, but their historic postseason run provided something that will last beyond Saturday’s heartbreaking finish: a foundation for the future and proof that St. John Vianney belongs among the state’s best.