Softball Coaches’ Association 2026 All-Division Teams
Below is the 2026 Coaches’ Association All-Division Teams. They are voted on by the coaches of each division. Shore Sports Insider will be publishing their own All-Shore teams at the end of the state tournament.
Coaches’ Association All-Division teams
American
Player of the Year
Madison McDougall, St. John Vianney
Pitcher of the Year
Emily Gaudio, Marlboro
Coach of the Year
Lisa Smith, Middletown South
Pitchers:
Angela Sasso, Colts Neck
Mackenna Savage, Red Bank Catholic
Riley Smith, Middletown South
Catchers:
Olivia Lombardi, St. John Vianney
Jayden Kane, Red Bank Catholic
Infielders:
Gabby Bryce, Colts Neck
Gabby Gonzalez, St. John Vianney
Grace Lombardi, Red Bank Catholic
Brianna Soto, Middletown North
Brynn Utter, St. John Vianney
Julia Watkins, Colts Neck
Isabella Wuelfing, Marlboro
Outfielders:
Adrianna Bryce, Colts Neck
Mia Collins, Middletown South
Abby Esposito, Middletown North
Mia Favato, St. John Vianney
Peyton McDougall, St. John Vianney
Utility Players:
Ashley Chen, Marlboro
Celia Collings, Middletown South
Jordyn Cowell, Middletown South
Colonial
Player of the Year
Elyssa Jamandron, Matawan
Pitcher of the Year
Julia Henderson, Holmdel
Coach of the Year
Nora Bosmans, Holmdel
Pitchers:
Kiana DeMonte, Freehold Township
Julia Henderson, Holmdel
Emma Kriegstein, Matawan
Catchers:
Natalie Clifford, Holmdel
Elyssa Jamandron, Matawan
Infielders:
Holly Bellofatto, Raritan
Hannah Bowers, Howell
Lila Houlihan, Raritan
Kate Murphy, Howell
Amanda Tuccillo, Holmdel
Emma Vanario, Holmdel
Outfielders:
Alissa Chavez, Freehold Township
Payton Fleming, Raritan
Addison Lawrence, Wall
Kate Martelliti, Matawan
Madison Regiec, Raritan
Katelyn Ruta, Raritan
Utility Players:
Molly Debias, Holmdel
Alyssa Morales, Howell
Madeline Musante, Freehold Township
Constitution
Player of the Year
Olivia DeFonce, Shore
Pitcher of the Year
Leah Garby, Manalapan
Coach of the Year
Dave Porta, Shore
Pitchers:
Leah Garby, Manalapan
Vanessa Karabin, Freehold Boro
Emily Torresdal, St. Rose
Catchers:
Ryleigh Cerco, Ocean
Juliana Cherbini, Manalapan
Infielders:
Nyla Bartuck, Freehold Boro
Kylie Courter, Manalapan
Kayla Delia, Shore
Ashley Koppelman, Freehold Boro
Morgan McGee, St. Rose
Taylor Scotto, Ocean
Outfielders:
Olivia DeFonce, Shore
Ayden Kampf, Shore
Elissa Lieberman, Manalapan
Kelsey Orth, Shore
Paige Sheridan, Freehold Boro
Calista Vowteras, Manasquan
Utility Players:
Jordan Diefes, Monmouth
Delia Gilmore, Manasquan
Colleen Zdan, Ocean
Freedom
Player of the Year
Isabella Maria, Donovan Catholic
Pitcher of the Year
Gylian Hixenbaugh, Donovan Catholic
Coach of the Year
Debbie Schwartz, Donovan Catholic
Pitchers:
Hailey Craddock, Central
Gylian Hixenbaugh, Donovan Catholic
Brooke Sutter, Southern
Catchers:
Jaelynn Nunez, Donovan Catholic
Grace Ostapovich, Central
Infielders:
Isabella Cino, Donovan Catholic
Maddie Duralek, Southern
Kendall Falduto, Pinelands
Abigail Krill, Southern
Cassidy Supplee, Point Boro
Jaelynn Witte, Central
Outfielders:
Leah Bollettino, Central
Jadyn Clayton, Point Boro
Summer Hunter, Jackson
Isabella Maria, Donovan Catholic
Jozlyn Peterson, Pinelands
Juliana Vignets, Donovan Catholic
Emily Zellman, Southern
Utility Players:
Mia Ingenito, Jackson
Caroline Kopp, Donovan Catholic
Kayla Rasmussen, Central
Independence
Player of the Year
Gianna Gomez, Barnegat
Pitcher of the Year
Gianna Gomez, Barnegat
Coach of the Year
Michael Palmieri, Barnegat
Pitchers:
Brianna DeLima, Toms River East
Gianna Gomez, Barnegat
Avery Nalducci, Brick Memorial
Catchers:
Maya Ballaccomo, Toms River East
Jadeyn Bodziak, Barnegat
Infielders:
Ella Fischer, Toms River South
Bridget Kane, Point Beach
Kylie Paladino, Toms River East
Brooke Rizzo, Barnegat
Olivia Stillwell, New Egypt
Makaila Wickham, Barnegat
Outfielders:
Cameron Carr, Toms River East
Aubrey Coulson, Toms River South
Brianna Dato, Barnegat
Addison Gallagher, Toms River East
Elizabeth Potts, New Egypt
Addison Tupper, Toms River South
Utility Players:
Caroline Davis, New Egypt
Carly Hobbs, Brick Memorial
Gianna Skwirut, Barnegat
Liberty
Player of the Year
Dalylia Lyon, Toms River North
Pitcher of the Year
Emma Mullins, Trinity Hall
Coach of the Year
Erica Eno, Manchester
Pitchers:
Julianna Garofalo, Toms River North
Gabriella Minneci, Manchester
Emma Mullins, Trinity Hall
Catchers:
Danica Rekus, Manchester
Juliana Vaclavik, Rumson-Fair Haven
Infielders:
Chloe Emmons, Lacey
Dalylia Lyon, Toms River North
Keira McNeil, Rumson-Fair Haven
Kayla Meyer, Manchester
Gabriella Minneci, Manchester
Giavanna Martone, Toms River North
Outfielders:
Riley Berry, Rumson-Fair Haven
Christine Flanagan, Manchester
Annabelle Gray, Manchester
Camryn Lynch, Toms River North
Skylar Minniti, Toms River North
Lizzie Sauer, Red Bank
Utility Players:
Lilly Bossow, Toms River North
Isabella Cellini-Winters, Manchester
Melanie Parker, Rumson-Fair Haven
Helen Taylor, Trinity Hall
Patriot
Player of the Year
Jordan Mulhearn, Brick
Pitcher of the Year
Sicilia Booker, Brick
Coach of the Year
Holly Walker, Brick
Pitchers:
Sicilia Booker, Brick
Lucia Fariello, Henry Hudson
Nicolette Sickles, Keyport
Catchers:
Ja’ziya Hunter, Lakewood
Miah Quarles, Neptune
Infielders:
Bella Anechiarico, Long Branch
Alex Belusko, Henry Hudson
Gabriella Flanzbaum, Keansburg
Jordan Mulhearn, Brick
Gisell Nieves, Lakewood
Dilenia Oquendo, Lakewood
Outfielders:
Gianna Cruz, Keansburg
Marishka Evelich, Henry Hudson
Ayana Gonzalez, Long Branch
Nathaly Izaguirre, Lakewood
Sadia Menta, Brick
Ava Mitchell, Keyport
Utility Players:
Taylor Diaz, Keansburg
Olivia Forgach, Neptune
Harmoni Hodge, Long Branch
