SSI Returning Girls Soccer All-Shore Players

With the 2026 fall sports season just around the corner, Shore Sports Insider kicks off its girls soccer coverage with a look at the returning standouts who earned spots on the Shore Sports Insider All-Shore Teams in 2025.

 

Shore Sports Insider Returning 2025 Girls Soccer All-Shore Players

 

First Team

Madeline Petrulla, Jr., Manasquan, GK

Samantha Mierzwiak, Sr., Red Bank Catholic, Defender

Samantha Price, Sr., Manasquan, Defender

Leah DiCillo, Sr., Central, Midfielder

Kayla Sasso, Sr., Manalapan, Midfielder

Kailyn Fitzgerald, Sr., Trinity Hall, Forward

Makenzie Memmolo, Sr., Howell, Forward

Jordyn Sullivan, Sr., Rumson-Fair Haven, Forward

 

Second Team

Jordyn Bauer, Sr., Marlboro, GK

Khloey Cilento, Sr., Point Boro, Defender

Ava Knight, Sr., Toms River South, Midfielder

Grace Pauwels, Jr., Red Bank Catholic, Midfielder (INJ)

Maddie Renna, Jr., Point Boro, Midfielder

Mia Fiorentino, Sr., Ocean, Forward

Madeline Nolan, Sr., Manchester, Forward

 

Third Team

Olivia Forlenza, Sr., Toms River North, Defender

Harmony Glover, Sr., Jackson, Defender

Kylie Keating, Jr., Howell, Defender

Alexis Sinatra, Jr., Red Bank Catholic, Midfielder

Katie Kirchner, Sr., Point Beach, Midfielder

Ella Cook, Sr., Jackson, Forward

Daniella Gordon, Jr., Toms River South, Forward

Carina Szorosy, Jr., Raritan, Forward