Shore Sports Insider Football Top 12, Week 12

We are down to three Shore Conference teams still standing in the state playoffs, and all of them are underdogs this week.

Who will punch their ticket to MetLife Stadium, or is this where the Shore’s postseason ends? 

Middletown North can pride itself on being the only Shore public school to win a sectional title this season after ending a 30-year drought by beating Chatham in North 2 Group 4. Now the Lions will try to reach their first Group final in history by beating a strong Northern Highlands team that just dispatched North’s rival, Middletown South, in a 31-7 win. 

The Group 4 semifinal also presents an interesting matchup for the rankings because it’s a common opponent with No. 5 Toms River North. The Mariners beat Northern Highlands 17-14 in a showcase game to start the season. A win by Middletown North gives the Lions the argument to potentially jump Brick Memorial for the No. 3 spot, while a loss might drop them behind Toms River North. 

Middletown North is coming off its first NJSIAA sectional title since 1996. (Photo by Tom Smith/tspsportsimages.com)  - Middletown North football

Middletown North is coming off its first NJSIAA sectional title since 1996. (Photo by Tom Smith/tspsportsimages.com)

On the non-public side, Red Bank Catholic and Donovan Catholic both cruised into the Non-Public B semifinals as expected. Now come the games where both of them could earn respect for the Shore on a statewide level. Obviously, the dream matchup would be both teams winning and then throwing down in a rematch for the Non-Public B title. 

RBC lost 35-28 to DePaul at a neutral site in the season opener in a game the Caseys led late. To get their revenge, they will have to beat the Spartans on their home field. 

On the other side of the bracket, Donovan Catholic will try to topple top seed and title favorite Paramus Catholic on the road. Much of it will come down to stopping Penn State commit Chu Odoh and the Crusaders’ running game, which put up 241 yards in a 55-7 win over St. John Vianney in the quarterfinals. Backup quarterback Rowan Martin also threw for 210 yards and two scores in place of injured star Walker Snee, so Paramus Catholic is a handful, but Donovan is a talented defensive team. 

1. Red Bank Catholic (8-3) – Last week’s ranking: No. 1. 

RBC's Rahmir Rivera (Photo by Patrick Olivero) - RBC Rahmir Rivera

RBC’s Rahmir Rivera warmed up for the Non-Public B semifinals with four touchdown passes in a quarterfinal win over Pope John. (Photo by Patrick Olivero)

The rematch we have all been waiting for is here, as the third-seeded Caseys advanced to face defending champion DePaul in the Non-Public B semifinals with a 35-0 win over Pope John. Sophomore quarterback Rahmir Rivera continues to finish strong, as he went 12-for-18 for a season-high 234 yards passing and four touchdowns, while sophomore running back Gabe Kemp rolled up 117 yards rushing and a touchdown and also caught a touchdown pass. Junior Jason Berecsky continued his stellar season with four catches for 93 yards and two touchdowns, and junior Ethan Kennedy had five catches for 109 yards and a score. Kennedy then picked up an offer from North Carolina two days later. Senior defensive linemen Lorenzo Tartamella and Jordan Key combined for six tackles for a loss and two sacks as the Caseys finished with 16 TFLs and five sacks in the win. Senior linebacker Luke Scaturro also had 8 tackles, 3 for a loss, and an interception. Next game: Friday at No. 2 seed DePaul (5-5) in the Non-Public B semifinals. 

2. Donovan Catholic (10-1) – Last week’s ranking: No. 2. 

Donovan Catholic senior running back Alex Staten exploded for a school-record 371 yards rushing in a win over Rumson-Fair Haven. (Photo by Patrick Olivero)  - Alex Staten

Donovan Catholic senior running back Alex Staten rushed for 188 yards and two touchdowns to help the Griffins reach the Non-Public B semifinals. (Photo by Patrick Olivero)

The fourth-seeded Griffins punched their ticket to the Non-Public B semifinals and set the single-season school record for wins with a 42-7 romp over Immaculata powered by a dominant performance by their defense and offensive line. They ran for 318 yards on 40 attempts, led by 188 yards and two touchdowns on 18 carries by senior star Alex Staten. Freshman tailback Carmelo Foendoe added 106 yards rushing and two scores on 19 carries. Sophomore quarterback Chris McClaren was flawless in filling in for the injured Kahden Davis, going 5-for-5 for 149 yards and touchdown passes to Aidan Kelly and TJ Hunter. Senior defensive end Jason Madden had 11 tackles, three for a loss, and two sacks to lead the defense. Donovan Catholic can get the whole state’s attention and fulfill its preseason rallying cry of making it to MetLife Stadium with a win this week. Next game: Friday at No. 1 seed Paramus Catholic (6-5) in the Non-Public B semifinals. 

3. Brick Memorial (9-2) – Last week’s ranking: No. 3. 

Season complete. The Millville team that knocked out the Mustangs lost 35-14 to a top 10 team in the state, Atlantic City, in the Central Jersey Group 4 final last week.

4. Middletown North (9-1) – Last week’s ranking: No. 4. 

Middletown North quarterback Derek Grasso threw a pair of touchdown passes in the victory. (Photo by Tom Smith/tspsportsimages.com)  - Derek Grasso

Middletown North junior quarterback Derek Grasso threw a pair of touchdown passes to help the Lions win their first state title in 30 years. (Photo by Tom Smith/tspsportsimages.com)

The top-seeded Lions won their first NJSIAA sectional title in 30 years with a dominant 28-7 victory over third-seeded Chatham in the North 2 Group 4 final to become the last public school standing in the Shore Conference this season. Junior quarterback Derek Grasso went 11-for-16 for 174 yards and two touchdowns, senior tailback Matt Belenko had 93 yards rushing and two touchdowns, junior wideout Anthony Christiani had seven catches for 92 yards and a score and Danny Sigler made three catches for 82 yards and a touchdown in the win. Senior linebacker Kade Little had four sacks, four tackles for a loss and 11 tackles as the defense bottled up prolific Chatham quarterback Ryan Hogan. Middletown North will now try to reach its first Group final in program history by beating the team that knocked rival Middletown South out of the playoffs. Next game: Friday vs. Northern Highlands (8-3) in the Group 4 semifinals. 

5. Toms River North (8-3) – Last week’s ranking: No. 5. 

The Mariners’ playoff run came to an abrupt end with a 41-14 loss to undefeated Washington Township, a top-three team in the state, in the South Jersey Group 5 final. Senior tailback Lucas Elias ran for 79 yards and a touchdown in the loss, and sophomore linebacker Finn Boland had 15 tackles, three for a loss. Toms River North’s season-opening win over Northern Highlands looks better and better after the Highlanders won a sectional title last week. It also might allow the Mariners to jump Middletown North in the final rankings if the Lions lose to Northern Highlands this week. Next game: Season complete. 

6. Southern (6-4) – Last week’s ranking: No. 6. 

Season complete. The Rams will have to replace all-time leading passer Carson Abbato, top receiver Chris Raub and RB/DE Levi Foote, but return the Iliescu twins at linebacker as building blocks for next year. 

7. Point Boro (7-5) – Last week’s ranking: No. 7. 

The Panthers’ playoff run came to an end with a 20-0 loss to a powerhouse Glassboro squad in the Central Jersey Group 2 final. Linebacker Luca Cangiano had 10 tackles and linebacker DJ Albanese had 8 tackles, one for a loss, and a sack in the loss. Point Boro will have to replace a stellar senior class that includes Cangiano, Albanese, quarterback Jake Clayton, defensive end Mason Morris, defensive lineman Aidan Dombrowsky and more, but do return a good amount of underclassmen with experience to keep the wins coming. Next game: Season complete. 

8. Rumson-Fair Haven (7-4) – Last week’s ranking: No. 8. 

Season complete. Junior quarterback Brady Williams was in attendance at Penn State’s game over the weekend and should see recruiting continue to pick up as we hit the offseason. 

9. Wall (5-5) – Last week’s ranking: No. 9. 

Senior defensive lineman Donovan Buist has a chance to be the Shore sack leader with one game left on Thanksgiving. He is tied for second with 12 behind the 14 by Pinelands linebacker Montrell Carter. The West Deptford team that Wall nearly stunned in the semifinals went on to win the South Jersey Group 2 title with a 28-0 victory over Camden Eastside last week. Wall can bolster its ranking by ending the season on a high note. Next game: Nov. 26 at Manasquan (6-4). 

10. Holmdel (6-4) – Last week’s ranking: No. 10. 

Season complete. Senior defensive back Michael Todisco finished with school records for career interceptions (10) and defensive touchdowns (5), and junior Anthony Serini has already become the school’s all-time leader in receiving yards (1,542) and receptions (92) with another season still to go. 

11. Middletown South (7-4) – Last week’s ranking: No. 11. 

The Eagles’ underdog run to a sectional final ended in a 31-7 loss to Northern Highlands in the North 1 Group 4 championship game. Quarterback Jack Schneider threw for 238 yards, senior Justin Rosato ran for a touchdown, and senior Owen Maguire had six catches for 89 yards in the loss. Drew Cerminaro had 12 tackles and Rosato added eight, one for a loss. Middletown South still has its Thanksgiving game left on the schedule, but it remains to be seen what will happen with the game if Middletown North reaches the Group 4 final because it can’t play both unless maybe it just plays a JV squad on Thanksgiving. Next game: Nov. 26 vs. Middletown North (9-1). 

12. Pinelands (11-1) – Last week’s ranking: No. 12. 

Pinelands wideout Dom Colosi recovers a fumble in the end zone against Seneca (Photo by SidelineSamsShots) - Dom Colosi Pinelands

Dom Colosi and Pinelands fell to Seneca in the South Jersey Group 3 final to end their magical season. (Photo by SidelineSamsShots)

The greatest season in Wildcats history ended with a 29-13 loss to Seneca in the South Jersey Group 3 final that denied them their first NJSIAA title in history. Junior RJ Clark ran for 70 yards in the loss, while junior linebacker Montrell Carter concluded an outstanding season with 14.5 tackles, three of them for a loss. Junior linebacker Paul Veneri also was everywhere with 23 tackles, two for a loss, A.J. O’Brien added an interception, and Xavier Jones had a 22-yard fumble return for a touchdown. Pinelands set a school record for wins, reached its first NJSIAA sectional final and won two playoff games after having won one in its entire history before this season. They also won their first division title since 1987, their second division title in history and their first outright division crown in history. They return Carter, Veneri, Clark and more talent, but their schedule should be ramped up considerably next season if they get realigned into Class A South. Next game: Season complete. 

Keep an eye on: 

Manasquan (6-4): The Warriors’ playoff run ended two weeks ago against eventual champion Glassboro, but they still have a shot to make the final rankings when they face No. 9 Wall on Thanksgiving. 

Scott Stump is the football editor and a reporter for Shore Sports Insider. He first started covering Shore Conference football in 1999. 

Email: scottstump25@gmail.com